Meta marked a real photograph of world leaders as false for 21 hours and then removed the warning without a word, and in doing so it proved that one company can rewrite the historical record for billions of people and they don't even need to answer to anyone.
The photograph is the 2018 G7 picture of Angela Merkel leaning over a table towards a seated Donald Trump, his arms crossed.
Our post sharing it on Threads was labelled "false information" within seconds, every new post sharing it was labelled with the same warning. The same warning went on posts by users in Canada and even on posts by celebrities. The actor Wil Wheaton, whose verified account shared our post's concerns about Meta rewriting history, was met with an instantaneous fact check, despite not needing one.
More than 3.6 billion people use a Meta app every day, and for most of them the feed is where the past now lives. This photograph is a public record, taken by a government photographer at a summit of seven governments, and for 21 hours Meta told everyone who met it on Threads that it was false.
If Meta can do that to one of the most widely published photographs of the last decade, it can do it to a photograph of a massacre, a police killing or an election count that only a handful of people hold. This picture was famous enough that people knew the label was a lie. The next one may have nobody else to vouch for it, and the label will be all that most people ever see.
Jesco Denzel took the photograph on 9 June 2018 at the G7 summit in Charlevoix, Canada, while photographing the event for the German government, and Merkel's office posted it on Instagram the same day. Snopes rated it true when supporters of Trump previously spread rumours that it was fake.
Meta's label said the post was false "based on a similar post reviewed by third-party fact-checkers". Tapping it led to a 2019 fact-check by the Brazilian outlet Aos Fatos, which debunks an edited version with Jair Bolsonaro in Trump's chair. That fact-check says the original image, published in June 2018, shows Trump. Meta took a ruling that confirms the photo is real and used it to label the real photo false. By evening clicking that same fact check simply said "This information is not available", and the label stayed in place for hours more with no source behind it.
This is where the real danger is. Thankfully, countless users had pointed out the reality of the fact check being used, regularly being the most liked comment under flagged posts. However, as soon as that link was removed from the fact check, there is nothing to prevent bad faith actors screenshotting this and taking that fact check into other networks or forums. How would that translate to a KKK attack with a false fact check, a Nazi rally or imperial crime?
The original photograph, posted by the German Chancellor's office on 9 June 2018
Meta did the same in July 2024 to the photo of Trump raising his fist in Butler, after fact-checkers had rated a doctored copy. Joel Kaplan, then Meta's vice-president of global policy, published a statement on 30 July 2024 saying its systems had "incorrectly applied that fact check to the real photo" and that its teams "worked to quickly correct this mistake".
Trump said Mark Zuckerberg called him to apologise. That photo flattered Trump. This one shows him sulking while the leaders of the G7 stand over him, and the label stayed on it for 21 hours. When it came off there was no correction notice, no statement and no phone call.
Meta blames its systems every time, and every one of those mistakes helps the far-right. If the systems work, this is intent to mislead. If they fail, they should have no say in what billions of people are told is false. Meta scrapped its fact-checkers in the USA in January 2025 and called them biased, gave $1 million to Trump's inauguration and paid him $25 million to settle his lawsuit. A company that pays the president and then marks a photograph that embarrasses him as false should have no hold on the historical record.
The reality is that Meta's systems act for Meta. If they work, this move was intentional, if they do not work, then they really shouldn't be in place at all.
Meta has ignored every question from Crust News since January, so we expect no explanation this time. We have asked Aos Fatos whether it knew its work was being used this way. The label went on because Meta decided it would, and it came off 21 hours later for the same reason. Save the photo, and keep what matters somewhere Meta does not own.