Security guards at Ed Sheeran's concert in Santiago, Chile on 21 November stopped fans at the gate for wearing the shirts of Club Deportivo Palestino, a Chilean football club founded by Palestinian immigrants in 1920.
The fans were told they could not go in dressed as they were, although nothing in the conditions published by the promoter, DG Medios, or the ticket seller mentions clothing. They got into the Estadio Bicentenario de La Florida only after arguing their case, by which time Sheeran was three songs into his set.
Sofía de la Barra, whose mother's family is Palestinian, wore a Palestino jersey and said staff told her "that maybe I would be let in wearing this". She took the shirt off and had a keffiyeh on underneath. A man named Rodrigo, in a club hoodie, offered to hand it over and collect it after the show, and asked why anyone should have to take off a football shirt to watch a concert. The fans who filmed the scene called it arbitrary discrimination. "Clothing is not a risk object," they wrote. "It is a personal and political expression that, in this case, is also legitimate."
Palestino plays in Chile's top division in the red, green, black and white of the Palestinian flag. Chile has the largest Palestinian community outside the Middle East, around half a million people, and the shirt is worn across Santiago every week.
Nobody who puts on a stadium show in this city can have been surprised to see it in the queue. The club expressed "deep indignation and rejection" at a "discriminatory act" it called "absolutely unacceptable", and said "no person should be discriminated against, questioned or barred from attending a show for wearing it". It has asked DG Medios to say who gave the order and on what grounds, asked Sheeran's team for its position, and offered legal help to the fans.
DG Medios has not answered. Neither has the stadium, and neither has Sheeran.
This is the same tour that dropped Macklemore in September after he spoke up for Palestine on stage in New Jersey. Sheeran said Robert Kraft, the billionaire owner of Gillette Stadium and one of Israel's most prominent backers in US sport, rallied other stadium owners to give him an ultimatum, that Macklemore went or the tour ended. Sheeran went along with it and said his audiences "do not expect a political forum". Aaron Rowe, Finneas, Lukas Graham and Sheeran's own backing band Beoga left the tour in protest.
Sheeran has since called the situation in Gaza "catastrophic and unjustifiable", but also put the blame on the genocide on "both sides", despite multiple UN reports finding Israel responsible for the horrific crime of genocide.
Sheeran and Kraft had both pledged $2 million to charities "in the region". Not only did they fail to announce if they would support Palestinian charities at all in that pledge, none of that money has ever shown up. It appears the promise was made as an attempt to save face when Sheeran's fans turned on him over his stance on Palestine.
Two months after his tour removed a musician for saying the same thing with more force, guards at his gate were treating a football shirt in Palestinian colours as some form of contraband, in a city where you must be stupid not to expect the shirt to show up.
A promoter that has worked Santiago for decades knew that, and so did the guards who stopped it. Nobody has shown that Sheeran ordered the move, but based on his own precedent, it's hard to move blame away from him. He is the one person who could have stopped this from happening, in the same way he was the one person who could have stood up for his fellow musicians, but didn't.