For the first time in more than two decades, the United States has not invited international observers to watch its federal elections. At the same time, the Justice Department says it will send a record 1,000 of its own monitors to polling places on Election Day.

The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, through its election office ODIHR, has observed every U.S. federal election since 2002: 12 rounds, including six midterms. This year it was not asked. The OSCE called the decision "regrettable" and "not in line with" the commitments the United States has signed up to, Human Rights Watch reports.

Those commitments are not optional extras. Under the 1990 Copenhagen Document, all 57 OSCE states agreed to let trained observers from the others watch their national elections. The governments that have recently refused are Russia, Belarus, Georgia and Tajikistan. Russia shut OSCE observers out of its State Duma elections last month.

In 2024, when Russia did the same before its presidential election, the U.S. mission to the OSCE issued a statement condemning "the Russian Federation's decision to deny OSCE election observers the opportunity" to monitor it. The United States now stands on the other side of that line.

The last time the OSCE observed a U.S. election, in 2024, it found it was well run, with candidates able to campaign freely. There was nothing in that report to hide from.

What replaces independent observers is the government watching itself. The Justice Department plans to send about 1,000 federal monitors to polling places, the largest such deployment it has made. Attorney General Todd Blanche defended the plan this week against warnings that monitors could intimidate voters. The NAACP has gone to court, arguing the deployment could jeopardize the election.

International observers answer to no candidate. Federal monitors answer to an administration whose president has spent years claiming elections are rigged against him, and has already tried to purge voter rolls with a database that flags citizens as foreigners. Turning away the neutral witnesses while sending in your own is not election security. It is choosing who gets to tell the story of the vote.